Enjoy FREE Shipping on Orders over $35!

Enjoy FREE Shipping on Orders over $35!

Cart 0

Lucky Penny Keychains Crafted With You In Mind

Choose a creative way to celebrate your story. Showcase your personality with an engraved Lucky Penny Keychain with charms of your choice. You can be as bold or as classic as you feel like. For example, we may have your love of pizza, your birthday constellation, or a happy pink flamingo already covered. Don't forget to check the trending Categories below to view our most loved Lucky Penny Keychains.

Awareness Ribbon Charms for Lung Cancer, Breast Cancer, Mental Health, Skin Cancer; Also, Suicide Prevention, Down Syndrome, and SIDS Ribbons.

Awareness Charms

Elephant, Flamingo, Dog Paw, and more animal lucky penny keychain charms.

Animals

Ice Cream, Pizza, Strawberry, plus more yummy treat food charms on a lucky penny keychain with a hand stamp engraved design on a penny.

Yummy Treats

Aquarius Sagittarius Pisces Scorpio Leo Libra Cancer Capricorn Virgo Taurus Gemini Aries Zodiac Constellation Lucky Penny Keychains

Zodiac Constellations

Volleyball, Soccer, Billiards, Baseball, Cheer, Fishing, Poker, and more competitive sports themed lucky penny keychains with hand stamped penny.

Sports

Popular This Week

South Carolina Palmetto Tree with Crescent Moon Charm with a Silver Flip Flop Charm together with a Lincoln Cent engraved with the State outline above the date of a Lincoln Cent to make a Lucky Penny Keychain.

South Carolina Keychain, Palmetto Tree & Flip Flop, Lucky Penny

Regular price $6.99

Pink Ribbon and Silver Hope Charm on a Lucky Penny Keychain engraved with a ribbon design in honor of Breast Cancer Awareness.

Breast Cancer Awareness Pink Ribbon Charm Lucky Penny Keychain

Regular price $6.99

A cross with a beating heart stamped above the date of a penny.

Cross Lucky Penny Keychain, Hand Stamped Cent w/Charm

Regular price $5.99

Monarch Butterfly Collection of 7 colors to choose from. Alongside a hand stamp Lincoln Cent where there is a matching butterfly engraving above the date.

Monarch Butterfly Charm Lucky Penny Keychain

Regular price $5.99

A Silver Elephant Charm attached to an engraved Lincoln Cent with a matching design above the date to make the perfect Lucky Penny Keychain.

Elephant Lucky Penny Keychain, Hand Stamped Design

Regular price $5.99

Choose an Angel Lucky Penny Keychain to remember your loved one. The silver angel charm is perfect with the hand stamped angel on this penny.

Angel Lucky Penny Keychain, Silver Charm Hand Stamped Design

Regular price $5.99

Autism Awareness Puzzle Piece Charm Lucky Penny Keychain with Smiley Face engraving above the date on a Lincoln Cent.

Autism Awareness Puzzle Piece Lucky Penny Keychain

Regular price $5.99

Two silver Sea Turtles-a mother and baby turtle-alongside a Lincoln Cent with an engraved Turtle above the date to make a Lucky Penny Keychain.

Sea Turtles Silver Charms Lucky Penny Keychain, Engraved Design

Regular price $6.99

This Lucky Penny Keychain includes a Bible, Cross, and Jesus Fish Silver Charms. The Penny is hand stamped with a cross design.

Jesus Lucky Penny Keychain, Hand Stamped Cent w/Charms

Regular price $7.99

Palmetto Charms shares the love for your pet with this Lucky Penny Keychain!

Paw Print Lucky Penny Keychain, Hand Stamped Cent w/Charm

Regular price $5.99

This 4-Leaf Clover is a perfect way to tell someone Good Luck! The silver Charm added to this Lucky Penny Keychain makes it an extra special gift. Cheers!

Clover Lucky Penny Keychain, Hand Stamped Cent w/Charm

Regular price $5.99

A pink and blue ribbon charm for raising awareness for infant loss, stillbirth, miscarriages. We attach this charm to an engraved penny.

Infant Loss (SIDS) Awareness Ribbon Charm Lucky Penny Keychain

Regular price $6.99

This Lung Cancer Awareness White Ribbon Charm Lucky Penny Keychain includes a Silver Ribbon engraved with the word "HOPE," and is paired with a Lincoln Cent that has a matching ribbon design above the date.

Lung Cancer Awareness White Ribbon Charm Lucky Penny Keychain

Regular price $6.99

This Lucky Penny Keychain combines a Silver Anchor Charm with a Hand Stamped Lincoln Cent showing the same anchor.

Anchor Lucky Penny Keychain, Hand Stamped Cent w/Silver Charm

Regular price $5.99

This Stethoscope Heart Silver Charm is perfect for Nurses, and the Caduceus symbol hand stamped Lincoln Cent is our way of honoring the Medical field.

Nurse Keychain Stethoscope Heart Charm with Caduceus Lucky Penny

Regular price $5.99

This United States of America Flag Charm is shown with your choice of hand stamp - a detailed flag design or the outline of the USA.

United States American Flag Lucky Penny Keychain

Regular price $5.99

A Lucky Penny Keychain with a Palmetto Tree and Crescent Moon charm, along with a silver Stethoscope Heart Charm.

Palmetto Charms & Etc.

South Carolina Nurses Lucky Penny Keychain

$7.99

Shipping calculated at checkout.

Full details →

Share this Product

Latest News

5 Reasons Why You Need a Lucky Penny Keychain

5 Reasons Why You Need a Lucky Penny Keychain →

We have you covered with a compelling list of reasons why you need a Lucky Penny Keychain!