Enjoy FREE Shipping on Orders over $35!

Enjoy FREE Shipping on Orders over $35!

Cart 0

Animals

Browse by

Sort by

Monarch Butterfly Collection of 7 colors to choose from. Alongside a hand stamp Lincoln Cent where there is a matching butterfly engraving above the date.

Monarch Butterfly Charm Lucky Penny Keychain

Regular price $5.99

A Silver Elephant Charm attached to an engraved Lincoln Cent with a matching design above the date to make the perfect Lucky Penny Keychain.

Elephant Lucky Penny Keychain, Hand Stamped Design

Regular price $5.99

Palmetto Charms shares the love for your pet with this Lucky Penny Keychain!

Paw Print Lucky Penny Keychain, Hand Stamped Cent w/Charm

Regular price $5.99

Two silver Sea Turtles-a mother and baby turtle-alongside a Lincoln Cent with an engraved Turtle above the date to make a Lucky Penny Keychain.

Sea Turtles Silver Charms Lucky Penny Keychain, Engraved Design

Regular price $6.99

Colorful Glitter Dog Paw Print Charm Lucky Penny Keychains with an engraved paw print above the date of a Lincoln Cent.

Glitter Dog Paws Collection

Regular price ~~$5.00~~ From $2.99

A Pink Flamingo keychain with a stamped flamingo bird above the date of a Lincoln Cent with a Pink Flamingo charm on this Lucky Penny Keychain.

Pink Flamingo Keychain, Lucky Flamingo Penny

Regular price $5.99

A beautiful silver dragonfly charm with a Lincoln Cent that has a detailed dragonfly design hand stamped above the date. This Lucky Penny Keychain is great for dragonfly lovers!

Dragonfly Gift Lucky Penny Keychain, Engraved Design with Charm

Regular price $5.99

A Silver Hummingbird Charm attached to an engraved Lincoln Cent with a matching design above the date of a Lincoln Cent.

Hummingbird Lucky Penny Keychain, Hand Stamped Design

Regular price $5.99

A Unicorn Lucky Penny Keychain with Charm and hand stamped design above the date of a Lincoln Cent. Choose from Black, Blue, Pink, Purple, or Red.

Unicorn Lucky Penny Keychain, Hand Stamped Design

Regular price $5.99

Rhinestone Honey Bee and Honeycomb Charms with engraved bee above date of Lincoln Cent on a Lucky Penny Keychain.

Honey Bee & Honeycomb Rhinestone Charm Lucky Penny Keychain

Regular price $6.99

Ladybug and 2 white flower Charms with an engraved Ladybug above the date of a Lincoln Cent on this Lucky Penny Keychain.

Ladybug & Flowers Lucky Penny Keychain, Hand Stamped Design

Regular price $7.99

Collection of 5 Owl Charms for Lucky Penny Keychain with Owl engraving above the date of a Lincoln Cent.

Owl Charms Lucky Penny Keychains, Engraved Design

Regular price $5.99

Cat face glitter paw print lucky penny keychains with cat's face engraved on penny and matched with a glitter charm paw print. Choose from black, blue, light blue, red, pink, purple, yellow, or green.

Glitter Cat Paw Lucky Penny Keychain

From $2.99

Seashell Keychain with option of engraving between a seashell and a starfish for a great Lucky Penny Keychain.

Starfish Seashell Keychain, Lucky Penny Engraved Stamp Design

Regular price $6.99

A Silver Deer Charm with an Antler Stamp engraved above the date of a Lincoln Cent to make a Lucky Penny Keychain.

Silver Deer Charm with Antlers Stamp Lucky Penny Keychain

Regular price $5.99

Detailed cow stamped pennies on 3" keychains with a white or black miniature cow charm.

Mini Cow Lucky Penny Keychain

Regular price $5.99

Frog Lucky Penny Keychain with a silver frog charm attached to a Lincoln Cent showing an engraving of a happy frog.

Frog Lucky Penny Keychain, Hand Stamped Design

Regular price $5.99

Silver Baby Feet and Yellow Duck Charms on a Lucky Penny Keychain with choice of hand stamp engraved Baby Feet or Rocking Horse design on a Lincoln Cent.

Baby Feet & Duck Charms w/ Rocking Horse Lucky Penny Keychain

Regular price $6.99

Fish Hook Lucky Penny Keychain, Hand Stamped Cent w/Charm

Fish Hook Lucky Penny Keychain, Hand Stamped Cent w/Charm

Regular price $6.99